2003-Josh Beckett, Florida (NL)
2002-Troy Glaus, Anaheim (AL)
2001-Curt Schilling and Randy Johnson, Arizona (NL)
2000-Derek Jeter, New York (AL)
1999-Mariano Rivera, New York (AL)
1998-Scott Brosius, New York (AL)
1997-Livan Hernandez, Florida (NL)
1996-John Wetteland, New York (AL)
1995-Tom Glavine, Atlanta (NL)
1994-No Series.
1993-Paul Molitor, Toronto (AL)
1992-Pat Borders, Toronto (AL)
1991-Jack Morris, Minnesota (AL)
1990-Jose Rijo, Cincinnati (NL)
1989-Dave Stewart, Oakland (AL)
1988-Orel Hershiser, Los Angeles (NL)
1987-Frank Viola, Minnesota (AL)
1986-Ray Knight, New York (NL)
1985-Bret Saberhagen, Kansas City (AL)
1984-Alan Trammell, Detroit (AL)
1983-Rick Dempsey, Baltimore (AL)
1982-Darrell Porter, St. Louis (NL)
1981-Ron Cey, Pedro Guerrero and Steve Yeager, Los Angeles (NL)
1980-Mike Schmidt, Philadelphia (NL)
1979-Willie Stargell, Pittsburgh (NL)
1978-Bucky Dent, New York (AL)
1977-Reggie Jackson, New York (AL)
1976-Johnny Bench, Cincinnati (NL)
1975-Pete Rose, Cincinnati (NL)
1974-Rollie Fingers, Oakland (AL)
1973-Reggie Jackson, Oakland (AL)
1972-Gene Tenace, Oakland (AL)
1971-Roberto Clemente, Pittsburgh (NL)
1970-Brooks Robinson, Baltimore (AL)
1969-Donn Clendenon, New York (NL)
1968-Mickey Lolich, Detroit (AL)
1967-Bob Gibson, St. Louis (NL)
1966-Frank Robinson, Baltimore (AL)
1965-Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles (NL)
1964-Bob Gibson, St. Louis (NL)
1963-Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles (NL)
1962-Ralph Terry, New York (AL)
1961-Whitey Ford, New York (AL)
1960-Bobby Richardson, New York (AL)
1959-Larry Sherry, Los Angeles (NL)
1958-Bob Turley, New York (AL)
1957-Lew Burdette, Milwaukee (NL)
1956-Don Larsen, New York (AL)
1955-Johnny Podres, Brooklyn (NL)