Judge Lopez Defends Her Rulings
She Spoke To Spanish-Language TV Program
A Massachusetts judge who came under fire for her
lenient sentencing of a sex offender defended her record and said
her critics were motivated by politics.
Watch NewsCenter 5's David Muir
Should Judge Maria Lopez Be Removed From The Bench? Tell Us.
In her first public comments since September's ruling, broadcast
Tuesday night in a Spanish-language television interview, Superior
Court Judge Maria Lopez refused to discuss the case directly, but
said she knows her rulings have been "just."
"I always tried to be just in all my rulings," Lopez told
Miami-based Univision. "That is my responsibility."
Lopez came under fire after sentencing Charles "Ebony" Horton,
a 22-year-old transsexual, to a year of home detention instead of
the eight- to 10-year prison sentence requested by prosecutors.
Horton admitted luring a 12-year-old boy into a car while
dressed as a woman, holding a screwdriver to the boy's neck and
forcing him to simulate sex acts.
Court proceedings, and her public chastisement of a prosecutor,
were caught on tape.
Lopez did not explain herself except to call Horton's crime
"low level" and say there were unspecified mitigating
circumstances.
A top Republican lawmaker tried to remove her from the bench.
"There needs to be some process by which they are held
accountable," said state Rep. Francis Marini, R-Hanson, who was
interviewed for the same program.
"There are other judges who may be white men who have done the same thing, but I didn't hear about those. It wasn't on TV. She did this on television in front of me and in front of all the people of Massachusetts, " Marini told NewsCenter 5.
He described his use of a little-known legislative tool, known
as a "bill of address," as not ideal, but the only avenue open to
him "to express my outrage at the sentence in which a convicted
kidnapper, child molester, was not given one day in jail."
Lopez, a Cuban emigre who became the first Hispanic woman on the
state Superior Court in 1993, described the attempt to oust her as
"all politics," and said she is held to higher standards.
"As a woman and as a Latin person you are always followed very
closely, and I know they have used different standards to check me
up," Lopez said.
"I know that the same ruling I made has been made by male white
judges and for some reason they do not attract the same grade of
attention that I did," she said.
Lopez said it is important for the judiciary to remain
independent.
"We are not politicians and that is why we are designated for
life, to make the correct decision, unpopular as that may be with
the public," Lopez said.
Before the ruling, Lopez had received positive media coverage
fueled in part by a flashy image. Asked if she would change her
image, Lopez said she would not. "I don't have to be popular with
anybody."
Previous Stories:
- April 13, 2001: Committee Considers Removing Judge Lopez
- September 15, 2000: Judge Removal Bill Won't Be Heard Soon
- September 11, 2000: Cellucci Asks Court To Cut Lopez's Duties
- September 7, 2000: Cross-Dresser's Sentence Sparks Concern
Copyright 2007 by TheBostonChannel.com. The Associated Press contributed to this report. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.










