sponsor
Homepage > Helen Thomas

Military Recruitment: An Invasion Of Privacy

Pentagon Abuses '01 Education Act To Demand Names From Schools

POSTED: 1:30 p.m. EST November 18, 2002
UPDATED: 2:00 p.m. EST November 18, 2002

Guess where the U.S. military has landed? On the grounds of high schools all over the country.

Military recruiters are using President George W. Bush's 2001 education act plus this year's law authorizing Pentagon spending programs to demand that principals hand over the names, addresses and phone numbers of all their students who are juniors and seniors.

What's going on here? What about privacy rights?

Some principals, citing laws saying that information on students is strictly confidential, were told emphatically earlier this year that little-known provisions of the military authorization measure and the No Child Left Behind Act "override any previous restrictions ... about disclosing student information to military recruiters."

Education and Defense Department officials insisted that educators must now notify parents at the beginning of each school year of their intention to give the military the information it wants about the students.

Of course, the officials conceded, parents may "opt out" and ask that schools bar any release of information about their kids.

However, many principals have been confused about the privacy issue and have not informed parents or students of their right to opt out.

Some have simply handed over the records without checking with parents or students. It's easy to see how the school officials were intimidated.

Last month they received a joint letter from Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld and Education Secretary Rod Paige saying that sustaining the nation's all-volunteer military force "requires the active support of public institutions in presenting military opportunities to our young people for their consideration."

The secretaries said the new laws require high schools "to provide to military recruiters, upon request, access to secondary school students and directory information (names, addresses, phone numbers) on those students... .

"For some of our students, this may be the best opportunity they have to get a college education," the two Cabinet officials wrote.

Then they provided the educators guidelines "for compliance with these new laws." And the guidelines made it clear that if they don't comply, the schools will face the loss of federal funding.

I deplore this coercive approach and the resulting loss of privacy. It was prompted by Rep. David Vitter, R-La., who got upset because some schools, especially on the East and West Coasts, were barring Pentagon recruiters.

Vitter said their action "demonstrated an anti-military attitude that I thought was offensive."

The Pentagon has said that about 15 percent of American high schools were "problem schools" for recruiters.

I don't object to recruiters talking to students who want to listen. But I'm not convinced that the military needs to venture into high schools. The Army, for instance, has 1,600 recruiting offices and 4,000 recruiters around the country, who, by the way, are doing just fine.

The Sept. 11 terrorist attacks caused a surge in patriotism and many young people rushed to join up.

Douglas Smith, an Army public affairs officer, said the service had met its recruitment quotas for two years in a row before Army scouts began hitting the high schools this year.

In the past the Army focused mostly on 21-year-olds. Smith said the goal this year was 79,500 and that so far 79,604 have enlisted.

However, the military might argue that its new focus on high school students is necessary as the nation prepares for an endless war on terrorism and for an allegedly short-term war with Iraq.

After all, the commanders are saying they will need up to 250,000 troops for the Battle of Baghdad.

But as the military recruiters expand their efforts in high schools, I think they should include other things besides upbeat spiels about educational opportunities and happy careers in defense of the country.

I think they should talk about the dangers of war and add a visit to a veterans' hospital where wounded soldiers, sailors and marines from previous wars languish with permanent injuries. War does that.

Serving in the nation's armed forces is a highly honorable profession. But as long as we do not have the draft, such service should be a truly free choice.

And the cost in human terms -- including the possibility of giving one's life -- should not be hidden in the selling job.

I worry that what happened in earlier wars will happen again -- that privileged students, mainly white, will find ways to get loans and scholarships for their college education without getting into uniform.

That means less privileged students, including poor minorities, who don't have such opportunities, will end up on the battlefront in greater numbers than their percentage of the total population.

It's true that for many young, deprived Americans of all races, the military may be a way out.

But they and everyone else should join because they want to and not because they feel -- or are led to feel -- that they can't do anything else.

(Helen Thomas can be reached at the e-mail address helent@hearstdc.com)

Desktop Alert

Desktop Alert
Download Desktop Alert, and get up-to-the-minute alerts:
* Breaking News Alerts
* Severe Weather Alerts
* Click here to download!

Job Searching Tips

Health Topics & Information

An alarming number of people live with pain. Whether yours is chronic or acute, we can help you make it stop. Get pain management tips here! More

Consumer Info


Sponsored Content Provided by ARA
Consumer Info


Sponsored Content Provided by ARA
Consumer Info


Sponsored Content Provided by ARA
Credit Report
See Your Complete Credit Picture. Get your Experian, Equifax & Transunion Credit Score & Report Instantly. View Online for free. More

Credit Report
See All 3 National Credit Scores & Reports Instantly and Online for free! More

Get Your Degree

Education is essential when you are entering the job market and is going to have a tremendous affect on the salary that you will earn while on the job. More